Dare I say…”healthier” Halloween candy? YES! I’ll make that statement.
Long before we faced food issues, my son didn’t like candy. You read that right. My son did not like candy. I’ll never forget the year he practically argued with his cousin because she couldn’t believe that he did not want the candy she was so generously offering. Or the birthday party where he asked if they had carrots or olives when it was time for cake.
I should’ve known back then.
It’s been about two years since we discovered by son’s sensitivities to high fructose corn syrup (HFCS), and artificial food additives (like food colors) which means that this will be our third Halloween where he will likely not enjoy anything he gathers that night. Even though our daughter doesn’t react as strongly as he does, we can absolutely tell when she’s had HFCS.
Halloween sounds really fun for these kids, right? Actually, they love it and have been looking forward to it for over a month.
Sure there’s the fun of dressing up, parties and the trick or treating adventure…and who doesn’t enjoy trying to figure out which friend is behind the silly or scary mask? Thankfully, for our kids the fun isn’t about the candy.
Once we get home, they’ll dump their loot out and we’ll sort through everything to pull out the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups that mommy and daddy like. All other candy goes into a bag that I bring to the office. Then it gets fun for the kids.
They each get to choose a handful of candy from the healthier assortment we’ve bought. Throughout the year, Yummy Earth Organics are a favorite for their suckers, gummies and hard candy, but especially now.
We also let them choose to buy a small item (like a book, CD or board game) or put the money in their piggy bank.
My prediction: my son will save the money for the skateboard he wants and my daughter will want something pink, or a new fairy.
How do you handle Halloween Candy in your family?



4 Comments
We host a Halloween party at our house with a Halloween Hunt (prizes at the end with natural candy, toys and such evenly divided), pumpkin carving, fire pit and smores. It’s a wonderful time and completely free of the give-mes and candy overload, but we still get costumes!
Rachel – Your Halloween party sounds like such a great time for everyone. I love the unique creativity, and that it’s centered around creating special memories rather than candy. Good for you!
Thanks for sharing.
So glad you posted this, I published a Healthy Halloween Treats post on my blog & Pinteresr yesterday and was so surprised by all the negative attention it received. http://kidsstuffworld.com/2011/10/healthy-halloween-treats/
I know I’m not in the majority here, but it’s nice to find like minded individuals. At the end of the day, I know my kids will bring home tons of candy I won’t let them eat. At least my choices can be used in other ways — for say, snack time or in kids lunches.
Many of the kids in my area suffer from childhood hunger, by handing out something that could actually be considered a meal replacement makes me feel much better than helping to rot their teeth.
Thanks for listening to my two cents
Well we like to hand out healthier candy or even non-candy options (like tattoos and stickers. But we also love trick or treating and I don’t want my kids to not experience the pure joys of “the hunt”. When we get home, we let the kids pick out a handful of treats that we approve of – 5 or so and they go in a jar for special times. The rest of our candy goes to the Troops through Operation Gratitude. We have done it for three years and love it!